If you listen to certain corners of the market, ESG is either over, politicised, or quietly being diluted.
It isn’t.
What’s actually happening across the UK, EU and internationally is more complex: recalibration, divergence and a shift from ambition-led rhetoric to rules-based implementation.
Europe: Expanding the Rulebook
The EU remains the most assertive regulator in the room.
The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) significantly expands the number of companies required to report on sustainability matters — including many non-EU businesses with substantial EU operations. Reporting must now follow the detailed European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), bringing far greater prescriptiveness and audit expectations.
Alongside this, the EU Taxonomy Regulation continues to define what counts as environmentally sustainable economic activity, influencing capital flows and investment labelling. The Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) is also tightening expectations around how asset managers classify and market funds.
In short: more companies, more data, more scrutiny.
However, there is growing acknowledgement within Europe itself that implementation is heavy. Discussions around simplification, proportionality for SMEs and phased enforcement show that even the EU recognises the operational burden.
This is not retreat — but it is refinement.
United Kingdom: Alignment Without Overload
The UK is charting a slightly different course.
The government has committed to adopting UK Sustainability Disclosure Standards (UK SDS), building on the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) framework — particularly IFRS S1 (general sustainability disclosures) and IFRS S2 (climate).
The Financial Conduct Authority is progressing Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) and investment product labelling rules to tackle greenwashing. At the same time, policymakers have signalled a desire to avoid unnecessary duplication and to remain internationally competitive post-Brexit.
The UK tone is pragmatic: maintain credibility with global investors, align with international standards, but avoid layering regulation on top of regulation.
Whether that balance holds remains to be seen.
Internationally: Political and Practical Divergence
Beyond Europe, the picture is mixed.
The United States has seen both progress and pushback. The SEC’s proposed climate disclosure rules represent a significant step toward mandatory reporting — yet legal and political resistance has slowed momentum and created uncertainty.
Elsewhere, countries are aligning with ISSB standards to create baseline global comparability. That in itself is a major structural shift: for the first time, sustainability reporting is converging around something that looks like a global financial reporting architecture.
At the same time, ESG as a label has become politically charged in certain markets. Some institutions are softening the acronym while quietly continuing the substance — focusing on risk, resilience, and long-term value creation rather than the brand of ESG itself.
So What?
The direction of travel is not backwards.
Climate risk remains financially material. Supply chain resilience remains fragile. Governance failures still destroy value. Social licence still matters.
What has changed is the phase we are in.
We are moving from aspiration to accountability. From voluntary commitments to structured disclosure. From narrative sustainability reports to auditable data.
The easy branding era of ESG is ending. The operational era is beginning.
The real choice for organisations is no longer whether to engage with ESG.
It is whether they treat it as compliance theatre — producing ever thicker reports — or as disciplined capital allocation and risk management.
Fragmentation may be uncomfortable. But maturity often is.
And perhaps that is where People, Planet and Progress finally move from slogan to system.
Subscribe for more reflections on People, Planet and Progress — where sustainability meets commercial reality.
#ESG #Sustainability #SustainableFinance #CorporateGovernance #PeoplePlanetProgress